Vindication for a minimalist

Throughout my residency, I never prescribed or recommended cold medicines to children under 12. The data showed them to be ineffective, and they were associated with cost and the potential for side effects – basically a no-win situation. I often got grief from parents looking for a quick fix, or at least some sort of intervention (to make the parents feel better, if anything), but I refused to budge. “Your child’s immune system is strong enough to fight this off on its own,” I would explain. “All we need to do during this time is to support her by keeping her well hydrated and her fevers under control.” I did feel bad that at least some of my parents were less than satisfied by this, but I couldn’t in good conscience do otherwise.
You can imagine my inner feeling of vindication, then, when the FDA recommended against the use of OTC cold meds in kids under 2 and announced investigation into use in kids over 2. It was one of those silent fist-pump moments. Now the FDA has announced some of the early results of that investigation, calculating that over 7000 kids under 12 visit ERs each year because of adverse drug events from OTC cold meds. While in the grand scope, this isn’t a huge number, it does seem like an enormous number once you realize that these events are – essentially – completely avoidable. We’ll see what comes next.
14 Feb 2008 ekchung
One Response to “Vindication for a minimalist”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Do you know how many otherwise very intelligent and caring doctors are ignorant about this. I remember my kids’ pediatrican who was a good medical school graduate and whom I admired a lot pushed all kinds of cold med onto my kids. She said, for comfort!
I didn’t know any better then. These days, I use hot Ginseng tea with honey and lemon juice, orange juice, warm bath for fever unless there is an infection. By the way, for a stuffy nose, a bit of minty ointment – Vicks Vapor rub or similar product- under nose makes a sick child breath so much better and sleep. It lasts a long time unlike the inhaling kind.